This One Product Is Quietly Draining Your Profits

If you can’t kill a losing product… it will slowly kill your business.

I know… that one stings a bit.

But I’ve seen it too many times.

Good people. Smart sellers. Hard workers.

Holding onto a dead product like it’s going to magically come back to life.

Spoiler: it won’t.

And the longer you wait… the more it costs you.

📖 The $8,000 Garlic Press That Taught Me Everything

Early in my Amazon journey, I launched what I thought was a winner…

A premium garlic press.

Better design. Better packaging. “Unique angle.” All the buzzwords 😅

I went all in:

• $5,000 in inventory

• $2,000 in PPC

• Endless late nights tweaking listings

At first… sales trickled in.

Then… they stalled.

Then… ads started bleeding money.

But here’s the part most people won’t admit:

👉 I knew it wasn’t working.

But I kept going anyway.

Why?

Because I didn’t want to be wrong.

So I told myself:

• “Maybe it’s the images…”

• “Maybe I need more reviews…”

• “Maybe next month will be better…”

Sound familiar?

Three months later…

I had burned through $8,000 and still had boxes collecting dust.

That’s when it hit me:

👉 I wasn’t running a business.

👉 I was babysitting a bad decision.

🔢 When to Kill a Product (The No-BS Checklist)

Let’s cut through the noise.

Here’s exactly how I decide today.

1. 🚨 No Traction After 60–90 Days

If your product has:

• Solid listing (images, title, keywords)

• Competitive price

• Active PPC

…and STILL isn’t getting consistent sales?

That’s a signal.

Not every product deserves more time.

2. 💸 PPC Can’t Get Profitable (or Close)

Ads are your truth serum.

If after testing:

• Auto + manual campaigns

• Different bids

• Keyword variations

…and your ACoS is still sky-high with no path to profit…

You don’t have an ad problem.

👉 You have a product problem.

3. ⭐ Reviews Are Telling You Something

Read your 3-star reviews like your business depends on it.

Because it does.

If customers keep saying:

• “Cheap quality”

• “Broke after one use”

• “Not as described”

That’s not a tweak.

That’s a fundamental flaw.

4. 📉 The Market Doesn’t Care

This one hurts the most.

Sometimes:

• The niche is too saturated

• The demand isn’t there

• Or your “differentiation” isn’t actually different

The market votes with clicks and wallets.

And silence is still a vote.

5. 🧠 You’re Emotionally Attached

This is the silent killer.

If you’re thinking:

• “I’ve already invested so much…”

• “I just need one good week…”

• “I can’t quit now…”

That’s not strategy.

That’s emotion.

And emotion is expensive.

🎯 The Big Lesson Most Sellers Learn Too Late

Killing a product isn’t failure.

👉 It’s resource reallocation.

Every dollar stuck in a bad product is:

• Inventory you can’t reinvest

• Ad spend you’re wasting

• Time you’re not using on a winner

Remember…

Most of you reading this are juggling:

• Jobs

• Families

• Late nights building this dream

(You’re not alone in that grind — it’s exactly what I see across sellers every day )

You don’t have unlimited shots.

So don’t waste them.

🧠 What I Do Instead (The Pivot Strategy)

When I kill a product, I don’t just walk away.

I extract value.

Here’s how:

Step 1: Liquidate Smart

• Run promos

• Bundle it

• Break even if you can

Cash flow > ego.

Step 2: Audit the Failure

Ask:

• Was it demand?

• Competition?

• Differentiation?

• Pricing?

There’s always a lesson hiding in the loss.

Step 3: Reinvest Fast

Take what’s left and:

• Launch a better product

• Improve an existing one

• Double down on a proven winner

Speed matters.

Momentum matters.

💬 The Rule I Live By

“Cut losers fast. Fund winners faster.”

Simple.

Not easy.

But simple.

✅ Final Takeaway

You don’t build a winning Amazon business by being right every time.

You build it by:

• Cutting what doesn’t work

• Doubling down on what does

Fast.

Clean.

No drama.

To fewer bad bets and bigger wins ahead,

Andy Splichal
Founder & Managing Partner of True Online Presence & Author of the Make Each Click Count Book Series

P.S. Overwhelmed by Amazon ads? I get it. Most sellers are throwing darts in the dark. If you want a pro in your corner running your PPC while you focus on growing your brand, let's hop on a call.
👉 Schedule your call here — we’ll see if it’s a fit 👊

P.S. Want a fast way to increase your Amazon sales? Take a look at my new software, Persona Factor, that uses your product reviews to optimize your product titles and descriptions.

Start For Free Today.