Stop Copying Products (Do This Instead)

If your product looks like everything else… Amazon will treat it that way.

Let me be blunt.

Amazon does not reward “pretty good.”

It rewards different.

And if your product blends in?

You’re about to donate $5,000 to Jeff Bezos’ next spaceship. 🚀

📖 The $4,872 Garlic Press Mistake (Yep… mine 😅)

Years ago, I thought I found a winner.

A garlic press.

Simple. Cheap. High demand.

I pulled the numbers:

• 10,000+ monthly searches

• Low price to manufacture

• Tons of sellers doing “okay”

I thought, “I’ll just do it better.”

Spoiler: I didn’t.

I ordered inventory.

Spent on photos.

Launched PPC.

And then…

Nothing.

Well, not nothing. Worse.

I got:

• Clicks but no conversions

• Sales but zero profit

• Reviews… trickling in like a leaky faucet

After 90 days, I had burned $4,872.

Why?

Because I launched a me-too product.

Same shape. Same features. Same boring promise.

Customers had no reason to pick me.

And Amazon? It just fed traffic to the listings already winning.

That was the day I learned this lesson the hard way.

🔢 How to Spot a “Me-Too” Product BEFORE You Launch

Let me save you from your own garlic press moment.

Here’s the exact process I use now.

1. The “Scroll Test” 👀

Search your product on Amazon.

Now scroll.

Fast.

Ask yourself:

👉 Do all the listings look the same?

If yes… danger.

Look for:

• Same images (white background, same angles)

• Same titles (“Premium Stainless Steel…” blah blah)

• Same bullet points

If you can’t tell them apart in 3 seconds…

Customers can’t either.

And confused customers don’t buy.

2. The “Why This One?” Test 🤔

Pick any listing.

Ask one simple question:

👉 Why should I buy THIS one?

If the answer is:

• “Better quality”

• “More durable”

• “High rated”

You’re in trouble.

That’s not differentiation.

That’s table stakes.

You need something concrete like:

• A unique feature

• A clear use case

• A specific audience

No clear reason = no sales.

3. Review Mining for Pain 🔍

This is where the gold is.

Go to 3–5 top listings.

Read 1-star and 3-star reviews.

Look for:

• Complaints that repeat

• Frustrations no one solved

• “I wish it had…” comments

If all complaints are already solved by competitors…

You’re late to the party.

But if you find a gap?

Now you’re onto something.

4. Price Compression Check 💸

Look at pricing across page 1.

If everyone is within $2–$3…

That’s a race to the bottom.

Margins will get crushed.

Ads will eat you alive.

And you’ll be stuck playing the worst game on Amazon:

👉 Who can survive the longest with no profit?

(Hint: It’s not the new seller.)

5. Listing Quality Gap 📸

This is the ONLY time a “me-too” can work.

If competitors have:

• Terrible photos

• Weak copy

• No brand story

Then you might win with better marketing.

But be honest.

If listings already look polished?

You’re not out-marketing them overnight.

6. The “Can I 10X This?” Rule 🚀

This is my favorite filter.

Ask:

👉 Can I make this product 10x better or different?

Not 10% better.

10X.

If you can’t clearly say how…

Walk away.

There are thousands of products.

You don’t need this one.

🎯 The Big Takeaway

Most sellers don’t fail because Amazon is “too competitive.”

They fail because they sell the same thing as everyone else.

And expect a different result.

Your job is not to enter markets.

Your job is to stand out inside them.

That’s how you protect your money.

That’s how you actually build a business.

Because let’s be real…

Most of you reading this are:

• Working a job

• Building this at night

• Watching every dollar 💸

You don’t have room for a $5,000 lesson.

(Trust me… I already paid that one for you.)

And if this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Most sellers are juggling life, budgets, and big dreams while trying to make Amazon work .

🗣️ Final Word

Look…

Amazon is still one of the best opportunities out there.

But only if you play it smart.

Don’t chase products.

Chase problems worth solving.

🙋‍♂️ Forward this to a seller friend who’s about to launch 💌

Andy Splichal
Founder & Managing Partner of True Online Presence & Author of the Make Each Click Count Book Series

P.S. Want to scale your sales without scaling your stress? I manage PPC for sellers who are serious about growth.
🎯 Book a free strategy call here — we’ll map out a winning game plan.

P.S. Want a fast way to increase your Amazon sales? Take a look at my new software, Persona Factor, that uses your product reviews to optimize your product titles and descriptions.

Start For Free Today.