Reviews in 2026: What’s Legal, What’ll Get You Slapped

If you’re still asking buyers to “leave a review” in your insert cards or follow-up emails, you might want to pump the brakes.

Amazon’s 2026 review policy update just dropped, and let’s just say… the gray areas are now pitch black.

No more playing cute.
No more “wink wink, leave us 5 stars.”
No more assuming Amazon’s too busy to notice.

Because in 2026, Amazon's cracking down hard—and sellers who don’t pivot are going to get buried.

📖 Real Life: The Seller Who Got Slapped (and Then Smart)

Let me tell you about Carlos.
Carlos was a solid 6-figure seller in the kitchen category.

He wasn’t doing anything crazy—just the usual:
• Insert card with a smiley “Let us know how we did 😊”
• Email follow-up sequence asking for a review
• Occasional “thank you” discount for those who responded

Harmless, right?

Well, in February 2026, his account got flagged.

Why?
Because under the new review policy, even implied incentives or review asks can be a violation.
Carlos wasn’t suspended—but he did get a warning and had 187 reviews removed.

Ouch. 😬

So what did he do?
He changed the way he plays the review game—and now he’s back on track (and sleeping better).

Here’s how you can too.

🔢 What’s in the 2026 Review Policy (and What It Means for You)

Amazon’s update boils down to this:

✅ You CAN:

• Use Amazon’s “Request a Review” button (via Seller Central or tools like FeedbackWhiz)

• Improve your product experience to naturally increase organic reviews

• Include neutral inserts (but no “ask”)

• Ask for feedback on service—not reviews on the product

❌ You CANNOT:

• Ask for a review in exchange for a discount, refund, or freebie

• Suggest or imply that only happy customers should leave reviews

• Use language like “We’d love a 5-star review!”

• Include QR codes or URLs that direct customers off Amazon to collect reviews

• Send multiple review requests beyond Amazon’s guidelines

And the biggest change?
Amazon now uses AI to monitor seller communications, insert cards, and even product packaging for policy violations.

Yes, that means your insert cards are being watched. 👀

🎯 Carlos’s Post-Policy Playbook

Here’s the exact 3-part strategy Carlos used to stay compliant and keep reviews flowing:

1. Go All-In on the “Request a Review” Button

It’s ugly, sure.
But it’s 100% TOS-safe and works.
Carlos automated it with a third-party tool—set it and forget it.

And guess what?
His review rate actually went up.
Why? Because it’s trusted and native to Amazon.

2. Turn Customers into Fans Through the Product

Carlos improved his product unboxing:
• Cleaner packaging
• Fun “getting started” guide
• QR code linking to a product tutorial (not a review page!)

This made the product more enjoyable—
and happy buyers = natural reviews.

3. Drive Post-Purchase Engagement Off-Amazon (Legally)

He added a QR code to the insert—
BUT it went to a value-only landing page:
• Recipes
• How-to videos
• Bonus usage tips

From there, he built an email list.
And after a few value-packed emails?
He nudged them toward leaving a review—outside of Amazon’s territory.

😉 Smart, right?

💡 Big Takeaway: Reviews Are Still Gold… You Just Have to Mine Smarter

The review rules are tighter.
But the opportunity is still there—you just can’t cut corners anymore.

Adapt, don’t panic.
Play long-term, not short-cut.
And for the love of Bezos, stop begging for stars. 😅

💬 “If it feels sneaky—it probably is.”

🙋‍♂️ Your Turn

If you’re using review tactics from 2023, it’s time to clean house.
Update your inserts.
Automate your review requests.
Build real relationships—not bots and bribes.

Because in 2026, Amazon’s watching—and the honest sellers are the ones winning.

🚫 Stay compliant.
💬 Stay human.
📈 Stay profitable.

Talk soon,

Andy Splichal
Founder & Managing Partner of True Online Presence & Author of the Make Each Click Count Book Series

P.S. Want to scale your sales without scaling your stress? I manage PPC for sellers who are serious about growth. 🎯 Book a free strategy call here — we’ll map out a winning game plan.

P.S. Want a fast way to increase your Amazon sales? Take a look at my new software, Persona Factor, that uses your product reviews to optimize your product titles and descriptions.

Start For Free Today.